Rustic, Creamy Portobello Stroganoff [Vegan, Gluten-Free]

Abby: "Absolutely delicious and fresh tasting" Read More


  • 3 cups portobello mushrooms (fresh, sliced)
  • 1 brown onion (small, peeled and diced)
  • 2 cloves garlic (minced)
  • 1 tablespoon vegan margarine
  • 2 cups vegetable broth (/stock)
  • 1 cup raw cashews
  • 1 tablespoon fresh thyme (or 1 tsp dried)
  • 1 tablespoon fresh rosemary (or 1 tsp dried)
  • 1 tablespoon fresh oregano (or 1 tsp dried)

NutritionView more

Sodium41% DV980mg
Fat49% DV32g
Protein39% DV20g
Carbs14% DV43g
Fiber28% DV7g
Calories510Calories from Fat290
Total Fat32g49%
Saturated Fat6g30%
Trans Fat
Calories from Fat290
Total Carbohydrate43g14%
Dietary Fiber7g28%
Vitamin A
Vitamin C

* Percent Daily Values are based on a 2,000 calorie diet. Your Daily Values may be higher or lower depending on your calorie needs.


Reviewer Profile Image
Reviewer Profile Image
Abby 6 hours ago
Absolutely delicious and fresh tasting
Reviewer Profile Image
Maze B. 7 Dec 2018
Sooo yummly, I used peanuts instead of cashews, which made it waaay more economic but still left the dish with a grrreat flavor!!
Reviewer Profile Image
Karyn 16 Nov 2018
Very delicious! Made according to recipe and it turned out great. Will definitely make again. We ate it over orecchiette
Reviewer Profile Image
Oswald 14 Nov 2018
10/10 these were soooo delicious and creamy. I halved the ingredients to serve 1, didn't have all the spices just dry corriander. Used extra garlic (3 cloves for just me) and added corriander, salt and pepper at the first stage not the last. Served on toast. Only took half the time (I don't have 50 minutes to make some sauce), just simmered on a higher heat so it thickened up quicker.
Reviewer Profile Image
Allyson M. 28 Oct 2018
Omg amazing!!! I used some coconut milk instead of vegetable broth. SUPER creamy.
Reviewer Profile Image
MshelD 28 Oct 2018
Good recipe it needed salt and pepper but otherwise good
Reviewer Profile Image
Pamela W. 10 Jul 2018
I left out the rosemary because my husband doesn’t like it. I added a tablespoon of vegan mayo and about a table spoon of nutritional yeast. We enjoyed it. Thx
Reviewer Profile Image
Izzy de la G 9 Jul 2018
Really nice! Would add salt, pepper, and white wine vinegar to give it more flavor.
Reviewer Profile Image
Joan Mitsinikos 19 Jun 2018
was good and extremely filling. i forgot the herbs and it was still great
Reviewer Profile Image
Abby B. 12 Jun 2018
was okay, had to add fresh herbs instead of dried. it was a little bland, i think next time i’ll use more veggies for flavor and more cloves of garlic. consistency was still good though!
Reviewer Profile Image
Shaina J. 9 May 2018
so good and all very simple ingredients! It was perfectly thick. My blender worked well for the cashew sauce after it sat in water for a little over 30 minutes. Can't wait to make it again.
Reviewer Profile Image
Tyler McGriff 14 Apr 2018
The picture makes it look thick but it was watery. I suggest having some bread to dip in. It was more like a soup
Reviewer Profile Image
Deane T. 12 Apr 2018
this is delicious! Made it for my non-vegan mother and she thought it had cream in it!
Reviewer Profile Image
Delicious! Would make again and again! Only suggestion don’t use a blender to purée cashews, doesn’t work all that well. Also it’s suggest dry herbs, i used fresh herbs and let them simmer for the 30 minutes with the vegetable stock. Flavor was perfect
Reviewer Profile Image
Brandy C. 28 Feb 2018
After reading some of the reviews I decided to skip the oregano completely and it wasn’t missed. I also added some crimini mushrooms b/c any mushroom will work as long as they’ve got some flavor. I doubled the recipe for a family of 4 and it still turned out great. We’ll definitely be making this again at our house!
Reviewer Profile Image
Kristin 19 Feb 2018
So good the first time I made it I’m making it again!
Reviewer Profile Image
Dory 13 Feb 2018
Made this last night for dinner. Non-vegan husband loved it! I - like many other reviewers - felt it was a bit bland. I will admit that using dried herbs instead of fresh was likely part of the reason. I will definitely make it again, though. Maybe I'll throw in a tablespoon of Worcestershire sauce and perhaps some white wine, too.
Reviewer Profile Image
Andra 12 Feb 2018
Outstanding! A new favorite in our household for sure. So simple to make with such great results, the best on pasta!
Reviewer Profile Image
Kelly Hockaday 28 Jan 2018
This was a good, hearty meal! The sauce is a bit bland so I'll put some chilli flakes in it next time but will definitely make it again.
Reviewer Profile Image
Debra 28 Jan 2018
Very tasty I added other seasoning to it and it’s made to perfection!
Reviewer Profile Image
Meagan 24 Jan 2018
Creamy, savory, and tasty.
Reviewer Profile Image
Jacinda 14 Jan 2018
Turned out great! It’s amazing what cashews can do for a cream sauce!!
Reviewer Profile Image
Tharasa 12 Jan 2018
my tastebuds never tasted any thing so good.
Reviewer Profile Image
Kim Evans 1 Jan 2018
Absolutely delicious!! And so simple and hearty. I added spinach and handful of baby carrots, served with brown rice. My first time making cashew cream and so impressed how simple it is and what a great dairy cream sub! And you can hardly tell the difference. Will def be making again.
Reviewer Profile Image
Diane Cillis 8 Dec 2017
Delicious! I used 4 large portobello mushrooms and served with mashed potatoes/rice. I will definitely be making this again and again.
Reviewer Profile Image
McCarthy 30 Nov 2017
delicious! even my 19 month old twins loved it. we served it over mashed potatoes. 😍
Reviewer Profile Image
The perfect creamy, flavor-filled, comfort food meal for a fall day. I added just a bit of sea salt, but this recipe was perfection. Will now be a staple in our home!
Reviewer Profile Image
Mpho Marothi 17 Oct 2017
It was out of this world!!! My new favorite dish!
Reviewer Profile Image
Emma Wainwright 3 Oct 2017
So good!!! Tasted like cream mushroom soup. Will definitely be making this again.
Reviewer Profile Image
Tina 29 Sep 2017
This is really good! I will make this again!