- 14 5/16 ounces oreos (whole, about 36 Oreos)
- 1 cup butter (divided)
- 1 1/2 cups creamy peanut butter (divided)
- 1 cup powdered sugar
- 1 cup chocolate chips
- 1/2 cup heavy whipping cream
PER SERVING *
|Calories1870Calories from Fat1240|
|% DAILY VALUE*|
|Calories from Fat1240|
|% DAILY VALUE*|
Kelly K 3 days ago
My family told me this is professional status! This dessert was a HUGE hit in my house! Thank you!
Laura Beth D. 7 days ago
Excellent!!! Making it again only two weeks later!
Tammy 18 Sep
very easy to make and sooo good
Tricia 15 Sep
Skip the Oreo crust, makes it wayyyy too rich. The peanut butter chocolate taste is exactly what I wanted though.
Kimberly 5 Sep
This was easy and oh so delicious.
Shannon O'Grady 22 Aug
Great, added a little whipped cream to the peanut butter layer and used a spring form pan. So good!
Holly S. 14 Jun
So easy and deeeeelish!!! Followed to recipe exactly and it was fantastic!
EmilyKing 12 May
My go-to dessert for anything and everything. The peanut butter part needs vanilla though.
Paige Myrick 27 Jun 2017
Better if it were healthier, but delicious! Next time I am going to substitute the cream.
Laura N. 17 Apr 2017
easy and tasty!!!!! it was a hit easter family gathering will make it agaib
YK 24 Feb 2017
I made this for a friend who loves Reese's and it satisfied their taste buds! It was a bit too heavy for me, though. I advise adding less powdered sugar. Overall: very easy and quick, and anyone who loves peanut butter is in for a treat!
Emily D. 22 Nov 2016
Wonderful! It's very rich though, and the crust doesn't turn out too crusty, it's much softer than I expected. Also, I would probably use less sugar next time, I had a super small slice and I could feel it. The top layer cracks, so the pie is a bit difficult to serve, but the taste is 100%.
Trenee G. 28 Jan 2016
The Oreos barely made it into the pie crust! I loved that this recipe had only a few ingredients and that it was so simple and quick to make. It satisfied my sweet tooth, but I can only have one very thin slice at a time. Having a bigger slice makes me feel like I just ate 8 Reese's cups. Still good!