FILTERS Reset

With Ingredients

Without Ingredients

Occasions

See more

Time

Tastes

Diets

Allergies

See more

Nutrition Per serving

Techniques

See more

Cuisines

See more

Courses

See more

Sources

See more

Brands

Dive into

Vanilla Rum Substitute Recipes

Vanilla-Rum Colas

Vanilla-Rum Colas

Martha Stewart pure vanilla extract, cola, orange wedge and 2 MORE
Apple Rum Raisin Bread Pudding

Apple Rum Raisin Bread Pudding

Once Upon A Chef whole milk, raisins, challa, large eggs, tart and 6 MORE
Spiced Pumpkin Eggnog

Spiced Pumpkin Eggnog

Serious Eats eggs, whipped cream, ground allspice, sugar and 6 MORE
Spiced Rum

Spiced Rum

Chow gold rum, star anise, clove, vanilla beans and 3 MORE
Bananas Foster Milkshake

Bananas Foster Milkshake

Food Republic light brown sugar, low-fat milk, unsalted butter and 4 MORE
Spiked Samoa Milkshake

Spiked Samoa Milkshake

Serious Eats unsweetened coconut milk, whipped cream and 7 MORE
Hot Buttered Vanilla Rum

Hot Buttered Vanilla Rum

MyRecipes dark rum, lemon rind, vanilla beans, butter, water and 1 MORE
Chocolate and Spice Eggnog

Chocolate and Spice Eggnog

Serious Eats vanilla extract, sugar, eggs, heavy cream and 6 MORE
Coquito (Puerto Rican Coconut Eggnog)

Coquito (Puerto Rican Coconut Eggnog)

Serious Eats evaporated milk, white rum, large egg yolks and 8 MORE
Tipsy Vanilla-Rum Sauce

Tipsy Vanilla-Rum Sauce

MyRecipes whipped cream, rum, butter and dark brown sugar
Spiked Iced Soy Chai Tea

Spiked Iced Soy Chai Tea

The Kitchn vanilla soymilk, spices, rum and cold water
French Apple Cake

French Apple Cake

David Lebovitz salt, dark rum, apples, baking powder, flour and 4 MORE
Dark 'n' Stormy Milk Shake

Dark 'n' Stormy Milk Shake

Chow twists, lime zest, ginger juice, lime juice and 2 MORE
Carey's Favorite Rum Raisin Ice Cream

Carey's Favorite Rum Raisin Ice Cream

Serious Eats dark rum, egg yolks, raisins, whipped cream and 2 MORE
Rhubarb Mojito

Rhubarb Mojito

Not Without Salt nutmeg, cinnamon, lime zest, vanilla beans, sugar and 6 MORE
Butter Rum Caramels

Butter Rum Caramels

Epicurious light brown sugar, vegetable oil, unsalted butter and 4 MORE
Candied Bacon Ice Cream

Candied Bacon Ice Cream

David Lebovitz vanilla extract, large egg yolks, half & half and 4 MORE
Toffee Eggnog

Toffee Eggnog

Serious Eats water, milk, heavy cream, eggs, dark rum and 3 MORE
Bread Pudding with Rum Sauce

Bread Pudding with Rum Sauce

Martha Stewart water, sugar, vanilla, white bread, milk, dark rum and 7 MORE
Banana-Brown Sugar Ice Cream

Banana-Brown Sugar Ice Cream

David Lebovitz sea salt, bananas, dark brown sugar, coconut milk and 3 MORE
Pineapple Upside Down Pancakes

Pineapple Upside Down Pancakes

Food Republic cinnamon sticks, milk, eggs, vanilla extract and 8 MORE
Roasted Pineapple with Rum-Vanilla Glaze

Roasted Pineapple with Rum-Vanilla Glaze

Martha Stewart unsalted butter, vanilla ice cream and 4 MORE
Spiked Do-si-do Milkshake

Spiked Do-si-do Milkshake

Serious Eats gold rum, whole milk, frangelico, cinnamon and 3 MORE
La Tarte (Vanilla-Rum Custard)

La Tarte (Vanilla-Rum Custard)

Saveur heavy cream, light rum, kosher salt, vanilla beans and 2 MORE
Rum Raisin Bread Pudding with Warm Vanilla Sauce

Rum Raisin Bread Pudding with Warm Vanilla Sauce

AllRecipes eggs, ground cinnamon, brown sugar, butter and 9 MORE
French Apple Cake

French Apple Cake

Once Upon A Chef unsalted butter, baking apples, granulated sugar and 7 MORE
Strawberries and Cream

Strawberries and Cream

Bacardi Mixers ice, BACARDI® Rum, vanilla ice cream and 3 MORE
Pirate's Last Call

Pirate's Last Call

AllRecipes vanilla, cocktail cherries, rum, white sugar and 1 MORE
Coconut Rum Cupcakes

Coconut Rum Cupcakes

How Sweet It Is baking powder, coconut extract, butter and 9 MORE
Hot Buttered Rum Apple Pie

Hot Buttered Rum Apple Pie

Leite's Culinaria pectin, granulated sugar, dark rum, apples and 9 MORE
Rum Cream

Rum Cream

MyRecipes grated lemon zest, fresh lemon juice, dark rum and 1 MORE
Pineapple Upside-Down Cake

Pineapple Upside-Down Cake

Smitten Kitchen all-purpose flour, baking powder, vanilla and 8 MORE
DIY Spiced Rum

DIY Spiced Rum

Serious Eats clove, cardamom pods, light rum, cinnamon sticks and 8 MORE
Ice Cream with Rum-Raisin Sauce

Ice Cream with Rum-Raisin Sauce

Martha Stewart brown dark firmli pack sugar, vanilla ice cream and 5 MORE
Rum Cake

Rum Cake

Once Upon A Chef cake flour, granulated sugar, unsalted butter and 10 MORE
Doughnut Pudding

Doughnut Pudding

Leite's Culinaria ground cinnamon, granulated sugar, whole milk and 8 MORE
Rum Caramel Sauce

Rum Caramel Sauce

Martha Stewart heavy cream, sugar, hot water, unsalted butter and 2 MORE
White Chocolate-Rum Shake

White Chocolate-Rum Shake

EveryDay with Rachael Ray white chocolate chips, milk, whipped cream and 5 MORE
Rum Truffles

Rum Truffles

Saveur cocoa powder, dark chocolate, heavy cream and 4 MORE
Rum-Spiked Horchata

Rum-Spiked Horchata

AllRecipes sweetened condensed milk, ground cinnamon and 6 MORE
Pumpkin Muffins with Eggnog Cream Cheese Swirl

Pumpkin Muffins with Eggnog Cream Cheese Swirl

The Kitchn vanilla, ground cloves, cream cheese, soften and 15 MORE
DIY Coffee Liqueur

DIY Coffee Liqueur

Serious Eats turbinado sugar, vanilla beans, light rum and 2 MORE
Cappuccino Rum Shake

Cappuccino Rum Shake

Epicurious ground cinnamon, whipped cream and 4 MORE
Brown Butter Banana Bread with Rum and Coconut

Brown Butter Banana Bread with Rum and Coconut

Joy the Baker plain yogurt, toasted coconut, ground cinnamon and 9 MORE
Fresh Fruit with BACARDI® Rum Cream

Fresh Fruit with BACARDI® Rum Cream

Bacardi Mixers fruit, eggs, BACARDI® Rum, vanilla and condensed milk
Strawberry Daiquiris

Strawberry Daiquiris

Food52 frozen strawberries, BACARDI® Rum, lemonade, ice and 2 MORE
Caramel Walnut Upside-Down Banana Cake

Caramel Walnut Upside-Down Banana Cake

Smitten Kitchen golden brown sugar, cake flour, sour cream and 13 MORE
BACARDI® Rum Balls

BACARDI® Rum Balls

Bacardi Mixers vanilla wafer crumbs, confectioners sugar, walnuts and 2 MORE
Hot Buttered Rum Batter

Hot Buttered Rum Batter

AllRecipes brown sugar, ground nutmeg, vanilla ice cream and 3 MORE
Breton Buckwheat Cake

Breton Buckwheat Cake

101 Cookbooks milk, sugar, large eggs, buckwheat flour and 7 MORE
Cappuccino Fudge Cheesecake

Cappuccino Fudge Cheesecake

Smitten Kitchen semisweet chocolate, vanilla extract and 15 MORE
Roasted Plums and Rum Raisins

Roasted Plums and Rum Raisins

Martha Stewart whipping cream, dark rum, light brown sugar and 4 MORE
Tres Leches Cake with Dulce de Leche Glaze

Tres Leches Cake with Dulce de Leche Glaze

Once Upon A Chef large egg yolks, dulce de leche and 13 MORE
Baked Eggnog Vanilla Donuts with Eggnog Rum Glaze

Baked Eggnog Vanilla Donuts with Eggnog Rum Glaze

Averie Cooks cinnamon, eggs, powdered sugar, eggnog, butter and 5 MORE
Rum Balls

Rum Balls

Martha Stewart light brown sugar, coarse salt, unsalted butter and 7 MORE
Coconut Rum Shakes [Spice Up Your Holidays - Week 2]

Coconut Rum Shakes [Spice Up Your Holidays - Week 2]

Baked Bree grated nutmeg, spiced rum, sorbet and 2 MORE
Rompope (Mexican Eggnog)

Rompope (Mexican Eggnog)

Serious Eats baking soda, lemon, pure vanilla extract and 6 MORE
Horchata

Horchata

Martha Stewart whole milk, ground cinnamon, pure vanilla extract and 5 MORE
Rum Raisin Cranberry Kugel

Rum Raisin Cranberry Kugel

The Shiksa in the Kitchen chopped walnuts, salt, white sugar and 16 MORE
Tartouillat (Cherry and Rum Cake)

Tartouillat (Cherry and Rum Cake)

Serious Eats cherries, salt, baking powder, milk and 7 MORE

Comments

# Now available on iPhone and iPad Now available on iPad

The Most Powerful Tool in the Kitchen

DOWNLOAD FOR FREE iPhone iPad
Why do I need to sign in?Smart recipe search. Personal recommendations. Re-discover food with Yummly.
You must sign in to use all of Yummly.6 Continue with Googleor" Continue with Facebook
By continuing you indicate that you have read and agree to the Terms of Service.
Why do I need to sign in?Smart recipe search. Personal recommendations. Re-discover food with Yummly.
You must sign in to use all of Yummly.6 Continue with Google" Continue with Facebook$Continue with Email
By continuing you indicate that you have read and agree to the Terms of Service.